I like John Gruber’s airport lounge analogy for iMessage. Michael Tsai takes it one step further to underscore how Apple’s control still twists what is possible.

Jarrod Blundy

Thanks for sharing. His way of leaning into the analogy aptly shows how Apple can be both in the right from a business owner and legal perspective (what @gruber was aiming for, I think), while they also turn a blind eye to the challenges/lesser experiences that their own customers face because of their stance.

Jay

@manton @gruber @mjtsai It would be like saying that AirDrop's being exclusive to Apple devices is anti-competitive.

The reason iMessage "feels" more anti-competitive is because more people are annoyed by its exclusivity.

Ernie Smith

@manton Gruber has presented the modern everyman tool, a smartphone that half the population uses, as a high-end exclusivity perk.

I cannot.

Michael Tsai

@jsit @manton @gruber AirDrop is a different situation because it doesn’t really lock you in. It is kind of anti-competitive in that no one is allowed to make a true competitor.

Manton Reece @manton
Lightbox Image